Skip to main content

Ask the Excluded, They'll Tell you what Inclusion Is


Blog post written by: Sadaf Vidha



Hello, my name is Sadaf. I'm a psychologist by profession. I would describe myself as a curious person. I love to envision a world where we are all respected and cared for, with our unique traits and struggles. I also happen to be from a conservative muslim family and have experienced patriarchal pressures firsthand. I hope that this makes me the right person to understand the ground realities of a lot of people. Lastly, I have helped a lot of clients deal with a range of mental health issues and the environmental contributors of those. Thus, I envision a world of socially just mental healthcare and this is my attempt to make the field ethical and accessible for all.

have a client currently in therapy, who has bouts of anger and sadness. His whole family is in therapy because I understood after assessing that his immediate and external environment had a large role to play in his current behaviour as well as how his life panned out.

For example, being pulled in multiple directions, his mom could often not care for him and would use violence to silence him when he would cry or demand attention as a child. Before he was diagnosed with a learning disability, he was hit at home and school as well as bullied by other children, as he could not study. The bullying and his mom’s use of physical punishment in turn made him absorb the idea that violence is the only way to get things done and get your due. After a particularly lethal suicide attempt, he was put in a rehab for over a year where he was chained and had to relieve himself in bed - note - there was no drug abuse from which he was experiencing withdrawal. He was just recovering from a suicide attempt.

Do we wonder then, why this young man is angry at the world and at his family? Why does he threaten and use violence to show his power and get his demands fulfilled?
And due to all this, he completed his 12th std pretty late and could not pursue mainstream education beyond that.

This is just a small peck of how exclusion works. The client manifested a lot of his issues because of what was done to him and yet, he is held responsible for what happened and what he became.

The new mental health act of India and the general tone in which the government and the medical community speaks, still talks of psychosocial disability as something that happens to people randomly. But the fact is, if a person has safety, a source of income, a community to belong to and a meaning for life, much of the mental distress would just not happen. And think about what a big role the government has to play for safety, income and community. Are our cities constructed such as to allow safe and fruitful interactions between people? Are our countries and houses safe? Do most people have anything left after making ends meet?

If the basics to life are not sorted, how can we keep putting a band-aid all the time when the symptoms show up? As data collected and analysed by Bapu Trust shows, poverty is greatly linked with distress. Even having a pakka house makes a sizeable difference in SRQ scores! And the data also shows that women, children and minorities are most vulnerable (BT Analysis report, 2015).

True inclusion would be when the government does large amounts of preventive work to address these basics, and also ensures full participation of everyone in some sort of meaningful existence. Or else, even with treatment, people are always likely to feel that they live on the outside, and they never truly assimilated. Post modern ideas tell us how socially constructed reality is. And how can someone feel okay if they are not included to create this shared reality?


Find more about Sadaf at,
https://whizwoman.wordpress.com/2015/05/02/statistics-stories-and-storytelling/
https://www.firstpost.com/living/as-mental-healthcare-remains-inaccessible-to-most-narrative-therapy-provides-an-inclusive-approach-4798091.html

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Is ‘mental health’ contrary to human rights?

Blog contributed by : Tina  Minkowitz Founder/President Centre for the Human Rights of Users and Survivors of Psychiatry When we go to a doctor’s office we may feel nervous, apprehensive.   We worry about test results, we worry about whether a treatment might do more harm than good.   We put our trust in the practitioner provisionally and hope she is trustworthy and competent.   But ‘mental health’ visits can be something else entirely.   Only in ‘mental health’ can a doctor end a consultation by advising your family to have you locked up under the supervision and control of medicalized wardens, where you will be forced to take mind-numbing and mind-disassembling drugs.   ‘Mental health’ and social failure ‘Mental health’ diagnoses, especially when consultation is initiated by someone other than the person herself, amount to a stamp of social failure, and set in motion a cascade of events leading to delegitimizatio...

Link between Diet and Mental Health - Role of a Nutritious Diet on Mental Well-Being

The link between diet and health is a well established one. Previous research has shown that there is a well established connection between a diet high on pro-inflammatory foods and depression. The benefits of having a rich, well-balanced diet on our well being and as an additional and alternative form of recovery is widely practiced at the Bapu Trust and is one of the core elements of the Seher program's 8 point framework intervention. Recently on Mad in America in an article titled "Study Explores Connections Between Diet and 'Serious Mental Illnesses'", Bernalyn Ruiz wrote about a recent letter to the editor published in World Psychiatry where data taken from the UN Biobank study highlighted the link between poor diet and severe mental illnesses. The suggestion made by the authors of the letter to the editor was that “further consideration should be given to increasing consumption of nutrient‐dense foods that are known to reduce systemic inflammation.” ...

From the Mental Health Movement to the Disability Movement - In Conversation with Yeni Rosa Damayanti

Left: Yeni Rosa Damayanti Recently, TCI Asia Pacific spoke with Yeni Rosa Damayanti, Chairperson of the Indonesian Mental Health Association, about her experience with international, regional and national advocacy in human rights for persons with disabilities, the ideologies she aligns herself with and where she sees and hopes to see persons with psychosocial disabilities in the future. Yeni has many years of experience working on various issues of rights for persons with psychosocial disabilities and her work has not been limited to the mental health sector, often collaborating and engaging with other human rights movements and the cross disability movement. She is also a member of TCI Asia Pacific and has strongly pushed for a paradigm shift in mental health advocacy to move towards the development sector and disability movement. She has considerable experience with advocacy and has been pivotal in changing mental health legislation to be more CRPD compliant and inclusive in Indo...