Making Sense of Trauma - Moving Away from the Disease Model and Embracing Cultural Responses to Stress

Noel Hunter recently wrote on Mad in America about how the 'trauma-informed trend often falls short'. In this article, she argues that while there are more and more mental health professionals who are becoming 'trauma-informed' and though the trend is moving in that direction, many of them have not moved beyond the disease model of trauma and are yet to embrace the holistic understanding of trauma and recovery.

She writes about the problem of 'invisible trauma' - trauma which does not check off the traditional, DSM led understanding of how, why and what trauma should look like and be caused by. She argues that trauma is highly subjective and "what is considered to be life-threatening to a two-year-old is very different than to a 22-year-old". She argues compellingly that being 'trauma-informed' for most mental health professionals is limited to that trauma that is easily "identifiable and measurable" otherwise it "apparently doesn't matter".

She goes on to write about the export of Western and Global North (American) models to understand mental health and stress, often leading to far larger and graver systemic problems. She uses the example of the import of a foreign model in Africa by the missionaries which led to the eradication of age old African customs and the implementation of apartheid. She argues that "It is time we started embracing diversity, difference, complexity, and humility. Mental health professionals would do well to consider that we are a tiny speck among the history of healers, believers, story-tellers, philosophers, charlatans, snake oil salesman, lovers, judges, and ideologists. No checklist or questionnaire will ever change that."

Read the full article here.

Comments

Is ‘mental health’ contrary to human rights?

Blog contributed by : Tina Minkowitz Founder/President Centre for the Human Rights of Users and Survivors of Psychiatry When we go to a doctor’s office we may feel nervous, apprehensive. We worry about test results, we worry about whether a treatment might do more harm than good. We put our trust in the practitioner provisionally and hope she is trustworthy and competent. But ‘mental health’ visits can be something else entirely. Only in ‘mental health’ can a doctor end a consultation by advising your family to have you locked up under the supervision and control of medicalized wardens, where you will be forced to take mind-numbing and mind-disassembling drugs. ‘Mental health’ and social failure ‘Mental health’ diagnoses, especially when consultation is initiated by someone other than the person herself, amount to a stamp of social failure, and set in motion a cascade of events leading to delegitimizatio...

Link between Diet and Mental Health - Role of a Nutritious Diet on Mental Well-Being

The link between diet and health is a well established one. Previous research has shown that there is a well established connection between a diet high on pro-inflammatory foods and depression. The benefits of having a rich, well-balanced diet on our well being and as an additional and alternative form of recovery is widely practiced at the Bapu Trust and is one of the core elements of the Seher program's 8 point framework intervention. Recently on Mad in America in an article titled "Study Explores Connections Between Diet and 'Serious Mental Illnesses'", Bernalyn Ruiz wrote about a recent letter to the editor published in World Psychiatry where data taken from the UN Biobank study highlighted the link between poor diet and severe mental illnesses. The suggestion made by the authors of the letter to the editor was that “further consideration should be given to increasing consumption of nutrient‐dense foods that are known to reduce systemic inflammation.” ...

A Response to the Lancet Commission on global mental health and sustainable development

Blog post contributed by Akriti Mehta More than ten years after the publication of a series of articles published in the Lancet [1] that heralded in the age of global mental health, a report of The Lancet Commission on global mental health and sustainable development [2] was released at the Global Ministerial Mental Health Summit [3] in London. It seeks to reframe mental health and place global mental health within the broader framework of the Sustainable Development Goals [4] suggesting future paths. It is commendable that the leaders of the Movement for Global Mental Health, many of whom have authored this report, acknowledge the importance of social determinants of mental health. The continued opposition to long-term institutionalisation is welcome. Furthermore, the focus on a life course approach is promising. Most importantly, the report stresses the need to move beyond just ‘treatment gaps’ and to recognise the importance of Sustainable Development Goals. ...

#WhatWENeed

Search This Blog